Promoted Posts On Facebook

by alexsavic on 30/05/2012

Facebook has just posted a demo video about Promoted Posts. This feature basically allows a Fanpage owner to make sure that more of their fans see timeline posts. Currently only a small fraction of fans actually receive Fanpage posts because of Facebook’s News Feed filter algorithms. Facebook revealed recently that only 16% of your fans usually see your posts.

When I first heard about promoted posts and the 16% filter, I really had to laugh. Two of the comments on the demo video page today really hit the nail on the head as to why:

“When like pages first started the whole idea was that people joined the like page so they could see your updates and engage with services they like. I dont understand when or why updating members of the like page has now become a lottery?? The features of the page have been reduced and handed back to us at a fee?? Not good” by Keysha Lrd Jordan.


“come on please… you first take 1/3 of my reach, now you take 2/3 of my reach again !!! i have built up my fan page, with my content, doing your page impressions for your advertisements, and now you take even that little from me for my work? making me to pay $5 for 5000 impressions? come on lol… just ruined months of MY dedicated, hard work. good job. i hope the money you earn with this will bring you joy” by Rudolf Bagi.

Both points are very true. If someone liked your fanpage, they did that so as to receive ALL your posts. Is it not then quite ridiculous for Facebook to limit that reach? Secondly, it’s just wrong to make Fanpage owners believe that by buying ads on Facebook that redirect to the fanpage, the Fanpage owner is buying reach. He is clearly not – he is just wasting his money, because he’ll have to buy that reach all over again with promoted posts.

As with all good things, maybe Facebook is coming to an end. These kinds of business practices just don’t seem right to me and I believe advertisers will quickly realize that pumping more money into this system makes no sense at all. Therefore Facebook please stop any filtering of Fanpage posts reach. If the fan does not want to receive a Fanpages posts anymore, they always have the unsubscribe button.

{ Comments on this entry are closed }

Krystal Peak reported on Vator about a new study released by Wordstream on how the Facebook Advertising system compares in size and performance to the Google Display ad network. According to their findings the average CTR for Facebook ads is 0.051%, well below the industry average of 0.1%. By comparison, the average CTR on the Google network is 0.4% making it almost 10x higher than Facebook’s.

Add to this the fact that the Google network provides both higher reach, far more ad formats, mobile compatibility and far more advanced targeting options, the question really does have to be asked – what is the point of buying traditional display advertising on Facebook?

{ Comments on this entry are closed }

Facebook May Have Just Lost Credibility On Incentivized Sharing Debate

May 11, 2012

TechCrunch today reported on a new monetization model that Facebook is testing that may lead to the social network losing all credibility around the incentivized sharing debate. The company is apparently testing a new program that allows private Facebook users to pay to have their Status Updates circulated to more of their friends and subscribers. [...]

Read the full article →

Amazing Wunderkind!

May 11, 2012

This is one of the most amazing interviews I have ever seen. This young man was 16 years old when he raised his first venture capital round. Truly exceptional. Congratulations Nick!

Read the full article →

Facebook Extends News Feed Offers Program To E-Commerce Retailers

May 11, 2012

We recently blogged about how the News Feed was far and away the most effective channel for non-paid marketing on Facebook, greatly more effective than Fanpage based widgets. Last week Facebook validated that conclusion by making its own discount/coupon code promotion system available to all brick-and-mortar businesses in the US. Pushing coupon code promotions within [...]

Read the full article →

Facebook Doubles Down On News Feed Marketing

May 5, 2012

As doubts grow over the standard Facebook advertising system, with issues ranging from vendor access to standardized measurability, the Fanpage News Feed is starting to look a lot more like an attractive marketing option to advertisers. Although not a model that fits into a traditional media-buy mindset, News Feed marketing can nevertheless be a huge [...]

Read the full article →

IKEA Launches Display Banner Containing 2800 Products

April 25, 2012

I was really excited today when I was sent a link to a new shopping banner from IKEA titled ‘The Smallest Store in the World‘, which said it contained over 2800 products inside the banner. Immediately I thought it was going to be a shop in banner solution, but unfortunately it was only a standard [...]

Read the full article →

Incentivizing Consumers Is Always Going To Be There

April 23, 2012

There was a really interesting discussion at the London Web Summit around mobile location services and how they are being used for marketing. The conversation quickly centred around social marketing and how shopping incentives are used as a marketing tool within mobile. Bonin Bough, VP of Global Digital and Consumer Engagement at Kraft Foods, commented [...]

Read the full article →

Consumer Trust In Word-Of-Mouth Marketing At 92%

April 21, 2012

Krystal Peak at Vator reported recently that a Nielsen study showing that while less than half of consumers today trust paid-for advertising such as TV or magazine commercials, a whopping 92% of consumers trust product recommendations from friends. Vator quotes Randall Beard, global head, advertiser Solutions at Nielsen, as saying: “Although television advertising will remain [...]

Read the full article →

Expandable Banner Ads Massively Outperform Non-expandables

April 17, 2012

We recently came across a report from PointRoll that shows that expandable banners ads significantly outperform non-expandable ads. The full study results were as follows: ” o For driving interest: Brand Search and Category Search – users who entered brand or category search terms in a search engine o For driving brand searches: Expandable ads [...]

Read the full article →